- Nassau & Suffolk County
Hear From Our Clients
East Hills is not complicated to love. It’s complicated to buy or sell without the right guidance. The village sits across two town jurisdictions — North Hempstead and Oyster Bay — and is served by three separate school districts: Roslyn, East Williston, and Jericho. The district lines don’t follow neighborhood names. They don’t follow subdivision boundaries. Two homes on the same block in Norgate or Lakeville Estates can fall into completely different districts, and that distinction matters enormously when you’re spending north of $1.5 million.
When you work with a local real estate broker who knows East Hills at the street level, you stop guessing. We confirm which district a specific address falls in before you make an offer — in writing. We understand the village’s two-layer permit structure, where work done on a home needs to be clean at both the village building department level and the overlying town level. We know what the Park at East Hills adds to the value equation, what the village taxes fund, and why the private security patrol and three-times-weekly trash service are part of the cost-benefit story — not just footnotes.
That’s what informed looks like here. Not a general sense of the North Shore market, but a working knowledge of East Hills specifically — its subdivisions, its tax layers, its school boundaries, and the thin inventory that makes every available home a high-stakes decision.
Lisa Caputo Sells Long Island is a Nassau County-based real estate brokerage affiliated with Signature Premier Properties — voted Best Realty on Long Island by Long Island Press readers. We are a Licensed Broker Associate and hold the Certified Buyer Broker (CBB) designation, which means when we represent you as a buyer, our fiduciary duty runs to you — not to the seller, not to the commission.
We have been selling real estate on Long Island for over 15 years and bring more than 25 years of professional sales experience to every negotiation, including formal training at Dale Carnegie and multiple Sales Institutes. At median listing prices above $1.7 million in East Hills, that background isn’t a credential on a bio page — it’s the difference between leaving money on the table and not.
We work with buyers and sellers across Nassau County, including North Shore communities like East Hills where the complexity of village governance, layered permits, and multi-district school boundaries demands more than surface-level familiarity. We’re available seven days a week, 9am to 9pm, because homes in a village with fewer than 15 active listings at any given time don’t wait for business hours.
Whether you’re buying or selling in East Hills, the process starts with a real conversation — not a canned presentation. For buyers, that means understanding exactly what you’re looking for, which school district matters to you, and what your timeline looks like. From there, we work to identify properties that fit your criteria and confirm the school district assignment by specific address in writing before any offer moves forward. That’s not optional in East Hills — it’s the step that protects a $1.5 million decision from being made on a wrong assumption.
When a home is identified, we walk you through the offer strategy. With inventory regularly sitting below 20 active listings village-wide and year-over-year price appreciation running at 13%, competitive offers in East Hills require precision — not just a number, but the right structure, the right contingencies, and the right timing. Our negotiation background means we’re not winging it in that moment.
For sellers, the process begins with an honest pricing conversation backed by comparable sales, followed by a pre-listing review of your permit history — at both the village and town level. East Hills operates its own building department, so any renovation, addition, pool, or deck you’ve done has two separate permit records. Getting those clean before you list prevents the kind of last-minute surprises that derail closings. From there, we manage the transaction through to closing, connecting you with vetted attorneys, inspectors, and other professionals who know how Nassau County’s attorney-review process works.
Ready to get started?
Buying or selling a home in East Hills involves more moving parts than most Nassau County transactions. The village’s incorporated status means it maintains its own building department, its own sanitation service, its own security patrol, and its own assessment roll — all on top of the county, town, and school district layers that apply everywhere else. A real estate broker who doesn’t know to check both the village-level and town-level permit histories isn’t protecting you the way you need to be protected at this price point.
We handle the full scope of what an East Hills transaction requires. For buyers, that includes school district verification by address across all three districts serving the village — Roslyn, East Williston, and Jericho — along with guidance on the village’s multi-layer tax structure so you understand your actual carrying costs before closing, not after. For sellers, we provide pre-listing advisory on permit readiness, pricing strategy grounded in real comparable sales, and professional marketing through Signature Premier Properties.
Beyond the transaction itself, we connect clients with a vetted network of attorneys experienced in Nassau County’s attorney-review process, home inspectors familiar with the luxury building stock typical of East Hills’s Colonial, Tudor, and New Traditional homes, and contractors who understand village-specific requirements. The goal is that nothing surprises you at closing — and nothing gets left unaddressed after it.
This is one of the most important questions a buyer in East Hills can ask — and one of the most commonly misunderstood. The village is served by three separate public school districts: Roslyn Union Free School District, East Williston Union Free School District (the Wheatley Schools), and Jericho Union Free School District. The district lines do not follow neighborhood names, subdivision names, or street patterns in a way that’s easy to predict. A home in Lakeville Estates and a home in Norgate can be in different districts even if they’re close to each other.
The only reliable way to confirm which district a specific address falls in is to contact the district directly and get written confirmation. We take this step as a standard part of buyer representation in East Hills — not something that gets sorted out after an offer is accepted. If school quality is a factor in your decision, and at the $1.5 million-plus price point it almost always is, this verification needs to happen before you fall in love with a home, not after.
Because East Hills is an incorporated village, it operates its own building department separate from the Town of North Hempstead or Town of Oyster Bay. That means any permitted work done on a home — a renovation, an addition, a pool, a finished basement — has two separate permit records: one at the village level and one at the town level. Both need to be reviewed during due diligence.
The practical risk for buyers is that a seller may have properly closed out their town permit but left a village permit open or expired. That open permit becomes your problem after closing — legally and financially. For sellers, this is exactly why a pre-listing permit review matters. If there’s an open village permit on your property, it’s far better to address it before you list than to have it surface during a buyer’s inspection and delay or kill the deal. Our pre-listing advisory process covers both layers as a standard step for East Hills clients.
East Hills is a thin, high-value market. Inventory is consistently low — in February 2025, there were as few as 14 active listings village-wide, down more than 22% from the prior month. Median listing prices were running around $1.71 to $1.79 million, with year-over-year appreciation of approximately 13%. The broader Long Island market was named the strongest seller’s market in the United States at the end of 2025, and East Hills reflects that dynamic in a concentrated form.
What that means practically is that when a home you want comes available in East Hills, you don’t have the luxury of waiting a week to think about it. Offers need to be structured correctly from the start — the right price, the right contingencies, the right terms. It also means that sellers in East Hills are in a strong position, but overpricing is still a real risk. Homes that are priced ahead of the market sit, and sitting homes raise questions. Accurate pricing based on real comparable sales is what gets you to the table and through to closing.
East Hills residents pay property taxes at several levels simultaneously: Nassau County taxes, town taxes (either North Hempstead or Oyster Bay, depending on your specific parcel), school district taxes, and village taxes. The village tax layer funds the services that make East Hills distinct — the private security patrol, the three-times-weekly sanitation service, and the Park at East Hills with its pool, fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, dog parks, and nature trails across 50 acres.
Understanding your total tax burden before making an offer is essential, and it’s more complex in East Hills than in unincorporated hamlets like Plainview or Roslyn Heights where there’s no village tax layer. The good news is that Nassau County has a property tax grievance process that allows homeowners to challenge their assessments — and we can connect you with experienced tax certiorari attorneys who handle this regularly. Knowing how to use that process is part of being an informed East Hills homeowner, and it’s a conversation worth having before closing, not years later.
Yes. New York is an attorney-review state, which means legal representation is standard and expected in every real estate transaction — not optional. This is different from many other states where attorneys are rarely involved in residential closings. In Nassau County, and specifically in East Hills, your attorney will review the contract of sale, handle the title search, coordinate with the lender, and manage the closing process. The attorney-review period typically begins after a contract is signed and gives both sides the opportunity to negotiate terms or walk away.
For East Hills transactions specifically, having an attorney who understands village-level permit requirements and Nassau County’s assessment structure adds real value. We work with a vetted network of real estate attorneys who are experienced in Nassau County closings and familiar with the specific complexities that come with incorporated village properties. If you don’t already have an attorney, we can connect you with someone who knows this market — that’s part of the service, not an afterthought.
A few things set East Hills apart from other Nassau County communities in ways that directly affect the buying and selling process. First, the three-district school boundary issue is genuinely unusual — most villages are served by one district, maybe two. Having three districts with non-intuitive boundary lines running through a single incorporated village creates a due diligence requirement that doesn’t exist in most other towns on Long Island.
Second, the village’s incorporated status means buyers and sellers are dealing with a full layer of village governance that unincorporated hamlets don’t have — a separate building department, a separate assessment roll, and village-specific permit requirements on top of the standard town and county structure. Third, the inventory is exceptionally thin even by Long Island standards. With fewer than 20 homes actively listed at any given time in East Hills, buyers are competing for a very small number of properties, and sellers are transacting in a market where the right pricing and marketing strategy matters more, not less, because the buyer pool for a $1.7 million home is always smaller than the buyer pool for a $600,000 one. These are the specifics that a knowledgeable local real estate broker in East Hills needs to be ready to navigate from day one.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in East Hills
