- Nassau & Suffolk County
Hear From Our Clients
Cedarhurst is not a market you can figure out from a spreadsheet. Homes here sell in the $800,000 to $1.6 million range, and the difference between a well-priced listing and an overpriced one isn’t just about square footage or condition — it’s about which side of Central Avenue you’re on, how close you are to the LIRR Cedarhurst Station, and whether the property falls near Motts Creek or Woodmere Channel, where flood zone status changes everything about what a buyer will pay and what their insurance will cost.
When you work with us, you stop guessing. Our sellers know their home is priced to attract serious buyers, not scare them off. Our buyers know they’re not overpaying for a location that sounds good on paper but doesn’t deliver the walkability, school access, or community fit they actually need.
The Five Towns market — and Cedarhurst specifically — rewards local knowledge. The Orthodox Jewish community’s lifestyle infrastructure, the day school ecosystem anchored by schools like HAFTR and DRS, the kosher shopping corridor on Central Avenue — all of it shapes demand in ways that a general Nassau County agent may not fully appreciate. Getting that right from the start is what makes the difference between a smooth transaction and a frustrating one.
Lisa Caputo Sells Long Island is built on one straightforward idea: real estate is too important to hand off to someone who treats it like a side job. Lisa is a Licensed Broker Associate and Certified Buyer Broker with over 15 years of experience selling homes across Nassau and Suffolk counties — and real estate is her full-time career, not something she fits in around other commitments.
We operate under Signature Premier Properties, Long Island’s fastest-growing independent real estate firm, with 20-plus offices across the island. That means our Cedarhurst clients get the reach and resources of a major brokerage without losing the personal attention that actually moves transactions forward.
For Cedarhurst buyers and sellers specifically, that combination matters. This is a high-value, culturally specific, tightly inventoried market where the stakes are real and the margin for error is slim. Our referral network — attorneys, home inspectors, contractors, insurance professionals — means you’re not scrambling to find the right people when flood zone questions come up or when a co-op board requires documentation you weren’t expecting.
It starts with a conversation. Whether you’re thinking about selling your colonial on a tree-lined block near Central Avenue or buying your first home in the Five Towns, the first step is understanding where you actually stand.
For sellers, we provide a complimentary comparative market evaluation — a real, data-driven look at what your home is worth in today’s Cedarhurst market, not a number designed to win your listing and then quietly drop after 30 days. From there, we work through pricing strategy, marketing approach, and timing — including seasonal factors that matter specifically in Cedarhurst, like the burst of buyer activity that typically follows major Jewish holidays in spring and fall.
For buyers, we start by getting clear on what you actually need: proximity to a specific synagogue, walking distance to the LIRR Cedarhurst Station, which school zone, whether the property sits near Motts Creek and carries flood zone implications. These aren’t afterthoughts — they’re the questions that determine whether a home is right for you.
Once you’re under contract, we stay engaged through attorney review, inspection, and closing. Our referral network means you’re connected to trusted professionals at every stage, and our communication style — clear, consistent, no surprises — means you always know where things stand.
Ready to get started?
We handle both sides of the transaction — buying and selling — and bring the same depth to each. For sellers in Cedarhurst, our work includes a complimentary market evaluation, honest pricing counsel, and a marketing strategy built around your specific property. In a village with almost no undeveloped land and a very limited pool of comparable sales, pricing accuracy is not optional. Overpricing in Cedarhurst is visible, and it costs you.
For buyers, we hold the Certified Buyer Broker designation — a formal credential in buyer representation that means we are working for you, not navigating a dual-agency situation that muddies the water. That matters in a market where the difference between the right home and the wrong one can come down to flood zone status, co-op board requirements, or a block’s proximity to the community infrastructure that drives value here.
Beyond the transaction itself, we provide references for real estate attorneys, home inspectors, contractors, handymen, and insurance professionals. For buyers purchasing near Motts Creek or Woodmere Channel — where the Village of Cedarhurst’s own zoning code contains specific provisions for flood-zone structures — having the right inspector and insurance professional from the start is not a luxury. It’s how you avoid a deal-killing surprise at the wrong moment. We handle short sales, co-op and condo transactions, and first-time buyer guidance.
It’s one of the most important questions to ask before making an offer on certain Cedarhurst properties, and not enough buyers think to ask it early. Parts of Cedarhurst near Motts Creek and Woodmere Channel fall within or near FEMA flood zones, and the Village of Cedarhurst’s own zoning code — Chapter 265, Article VI — contains specific provisions for structures in those areas, including rules about raising structures and flood vent requirements. That affects what renovations are possible, what permits are required, and how a lender will approach the transaction.
From a cost standpoint, flood insurance is a real carrying expense that needs to be factored into your budget before you fall in love with a property. An elevation certificate is typically required, and the cost of insurance varies significantly depending on the specific flood zone designation and the elevation of the structure. We flag this before you’re under contract — not after the inspection report surfaces it as a problem. Our referral network includes inspectors and insurance professionals who are familiar with Cedarhurst’s South Shore geography and can give you accurate information early in the process.
Cedarhurst is a high-demand, low-inventory market operating at a price tier well above the Nassau County average. Homes here typically sell in the $800,000 to $1.6 million range, and the village covers just 0.7 square miles — almost entirely built out, with virtually no new construction except occasional teardown rebuilds or gut renovations. That compressed geography means the supply of available homes at any given time is extremely limited, and well-priced properties attract serious attention quickly.
Across Long Island, Nassau County’s median home price reached $810,000 in early 2025, up approximately 11% year-over-year, and inventory remains near historic lows. In a market this tight, buyers who are well-represented — with an agent who has a strong professional network and hears about opportunities before they hit the MLS — have a real advantage. For sellers in Cedarhurst, the low inventory environment is favorable, but overpricing is still a risk. With very few comparable sales to work from in a village this size, an inflated list price stands out and sits — which ultimately costs you more than pricing it right from the start.
Because Cedarhurst is not a generic suburb — it’s a community where lifestyle infrastructure drives value in very specific ways. Proximity to Central Avenue, the village’s walkable commercial corridor with its concentration of kosher restaurants, bakeries, and specialty shops, carries a real premium for buyers who want to walk to shopping and dining. Proximity to a specific synagogue matters enormously for observant buyers who need to be within walking distance for Shabbat. And proximity to the LIRR Cedarhurst Station on the Far Rockaway Branch — which provides direct service to Penn Station — affects value for buyers who commute to Manhattan.
Two homes that look identical on paper can carry meaningfully different prices based on which side of a street they’re on or how many blocks they sit from Central Avenue. We understand those community-driven dynamics and price accordingly. This is why hyperlocal knowledge isn’t a marketing phrase in Cedarhurst — it’s a practical requirement.
A Certified Buyer Broker, or CBB, is a formal designation for agents who specialize in representing buyers — not sellers, and not both sides at once. It means the agent has completed specific training in buyer representation and is formally committed to advocating for the buyer’s interests throughout the transaction. That’s different from a general real estate license, which allows an agent to represent either side without any specialized buyer-advocacy training.
In a market like Cedarhurst, where transactions routinely exceed $1 million and involve layers of complexity — flood zone considerations, co-op board requirements, community-specific pricing dynamics — having an agent who is unambiguously in your corner matters. Dual agency, where one agent represents both buyer and seller, creates a conflict of interest that can work against you at the negotiating table. Lisa holds this designation, which means when you’re buying a home in Cedarhurst, she is working for you — on your timeline, toward your outcome, with your interests as the only priority.
The National Association of Realtors settlement that took effect in August 2024 changed a few things that buyers and sellers in Cedarhurst should understand. The most significant change for buyers is that you are now required to sign a written buyer-agent compensation agreement before touring homes with a buyer’s agent. This agreement outlines how your agent will be compensated, which removes a lot of the ambiguity that previously existed — only 37% of buyers knew exactly how much their agent was paid before these changes.
For sellers, the settlement means you are no longer required to offer buyer-agent compensation through the MLS. Commissions are fully negotiable, and the structure of how compensation flows through a transaction has become more transparent on both sides. What hasn’t changed is the value of having a skilled, full-time agent representing you in a high-stakes market. In Cedarhurst, where a 1% pricing error on a $1 million home is $10,000, the expertise and local knowledge an experienced agent brings to the table is not an abstract benefit — it’s a measurable one. We’re happy to walk you through exactly how compensation works before you commit to anything.
For most Cedarhurst buyers and sellers, yes — and the reason comes down to what actually drives outcomes in this specific market. Large national franchise brands have name recognition, but they don’t have agents who know why a home on a specific block near Central Avenue commands a premium, or which properties near Woodmere Channel are going to raise flood insurance questions, or how the pre-Passover and pre-Rosh Hashanah periods affect transaction timelines in a community where those dates shape family decisions.
Cedarhurst is a village where 95% of residents work in white-collar professions, where home values have more than tripled since 2000, and where the community’s cultural identity directly shapes what buyers are looking for and what they’ll pay. A local real estate agency in Cedarhurst, NY — one backed by a strong brokerage like Signature Premier Properties, Long Island’s fastest-growing independent firm — gives you the market reach of a major operation with the community fluency that national brands simply cannot replicate. That combination is what moves transactions forward cleanly in a market this specific.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in Cedarhurst
