- Nassau & Suffolk County
Hear From Our Clients
Manhasset is not a single market wearing one name. It’s Munsey Park, Plandome, the Strathmore sections, Shorehaven, Norgate — each with its own character, governance, and pricing reality, all sharing the same 11030 ZIP code. When you’re buying or selling here, the difference between a block in an incorporated village and one in an unincorporated pocket isn’t a technicality. It affects zoning, governance, and in some cases, whether a property actually falls within the Manhasset Union Free School District boundary.
That boundary matters enormously. Families relocate specifically to access a district ranked in the top 5% of public schools in New York State. Getting it wrong isn’t just inconvenient — at this price point, it’s a six-figure mistake.
On the selling side, Manhasset’s median sale price sits around $2.3 million, up 16% year-over-year. Nearly half the homes in this community were built before 1940. Pre-war colonials and Tudor-style properties carry decades of renovation history, and buyers here are sophisticated enough to ask the hard questions during inspection. Pricing one of these homes accurately — not optimistically, not conservatively, but accurately — requires someone who has actually worked through these transactions in Nassau County, not someone running comps from a national database.
When you work with us, you stop guessing and start making decisions with real information behind them.
Lisa Caputo Sells Long Island is a licensed Broker Associate and Certified Buyer Broker operating across Nassau County, including Manhasset and the surrounding North Shore communities. With over 15 years of Long Island real estate experience, I’ve worked through the full range of residential transactions — single-family homes, condos, co-ops, short sales, and investment properties — across the market conditions that actually define this area.
What sets this apart from the institutional brokerages with offices on Plandome Road is simple: you get one person who is fully invested in your outcome, not a rotating team of agents managing volume. My clients consistently describe me as someone who communicates clearly, prices honestly, and stays reachable throughout the process — not just at the listing appointment.
I operate under Signature Premier Properties, Long Island’s fastest-growing independent brokerage with 20+ offices across Nassau and Suffolk counties. That means the MLS access, marketing reach, and professional infrastructure of a major firm — delivered with the personal attention that a $2+ million Manhasset transaction actually requires.
It starts with a conversation. Whether you’re buying or selling, the first step is understanding where you actually stand. For sellers, that means a complimentary comparative market evaluation — a professional assessment of what your home is worth in today’s Manhasset market, with no obligation attached. Given that the median price has risen over 115% since 2012, many long-term homeowners are sitting on equity they haven’t fully accounted for.
For buyers, the process begins with getting clear on what you need — and what Manhasset’s sub-neighborhoods can realistically offer within your parameters. Since August 2024, buyers are required to sign a written buyer-agent compensation agreement before touring homes. I walk you through exactly what that means, what you’re agreeing to, and what you’re getting in return.
From there, the process moves through offer strategy, negotiation, inspection, and attorney review. In a market where active listings number in the low dozens at any given time and the average days on market is 46 days, timing and preparation matter. My referral network — attorneys, inspectors, contractors familiar with Manhasset’s pre-war housing stock — is already in place when you need it. The goal at every stage is that you know exactly where things stand and why.
Ready to get started?
Whether you’re buying or selling in Manhasset, the services I provide are built around the specific realities of this market. For sellers, that includes an accurate comparative market evaluation, a pricing strategy grounded in actual Nassau County comps, professional marketing through Signature Premier Properties’ MLS access and network, and guidance through every stage from listing to closing.
Given that nearly half of Manhasset’s homes were built before 1940, I help sellers understand how to present and position a pre-war property — what buyers will scrutinize, what to address proactively, and how to avoid the price reductions that come from being caught off guard.
For buyers, my Certified Buyer Broker designation means dedicated representation — not split loyalty. I help buyers understand which parcels fall within the Manhasset Union Free School District, which sub-neighborhoods carry different governance structures, and how to build an offer that holds up in a competitive situation. For buyers navigating jumbo mortgage financing at this price tier, that preparation makes a real difference.
Across both sides, you get access to my established referral network: attorneys, home inspectors experienced with older North Shore housing stock, contractors, and handymen. This isn’t a list of names — it’s a network built from years of working actual transactions in Manhasset and Nassau County. For anyone not yet ready to commit, a free home valuation is always available as a starting point with zero pressure attached.
A real estate agency in Manhasset, NY does a lot more than schedule showings. At this price point and in this specific market, a buyer’s agent is the person helping you understand which sub-neighborhood you’re actually buying into — because Manhasset’s greater area includes incorporated villages like Munsey Park and Plandome alongside unincorporated pockets like the Strathmore sections, and those distinctions affect governance, zoning, and sometimes school district boundaries.
Your agent also helps you build a competitive offer in a market where active inventory regularly sits below 30 homes. That means knowing how to structure terms, how to move quickly when the right property appears, and how to navigate the inspection process on a pre-war home without losing the deal or getting blindsided post-closing. Since August 2024, buyers are also required to sign a written compensation agreement with their agent before touring homes — a good buyer’s agent will explain that clearly upfront so there’s no confusion about what you’re agreeing to or what it costs.
Manhasset’s market has been consistently strong. The median sale price is approximately $2.3 million as of 2025, up roughly 16% year-over-year. That appreciation isn’t a recent spike — the median price in Manhasset has risen over 115% since 2012, reflecting the community’s sustained desirability among North Shore buyers and Manhattan commuters.
Inventory remains tight. At any given time, there are roughly 27 active listings in Manhasset, and approximately 174 homes sell annually. The average days on market is around 46 days, which means well-priced homes move. The buyers in this market are typically high-income professionals — many commuting to Manhattan via the LIRR Port Washington Branch — and they’ve done their research before they call an agent. In that environment, accurate pricing and strong preparation on both sides of the transaction are what separate smooth closings from deals that fall apart.
It matters quite a bit, and it’s one of the most underappreciated aspects of buying in Manhasset. The greater Manhasset area includes three fully incorporated villages — Munsey Park, Plandome, and Plandome Heights — along with portions of Flower Hill, Plandome Manor, and North Hills, plus a range of unincorporated sub-neighborhoods like the Strathmore sections, Shorehaven, Norgate, and Terrace Manor. All of these share the 11030 ZIP code, but they don’t all share the same governance structure or zoning rules.
For families targeting the Manhasset Union Free School District — which is ranked in the top 5% of public schools in New York State — knowing exactly which parcels fall within the district boundary is essential. The school district is frequently the primary reason buyers choose Manhasset over neighboring communities. An agent who doesn’t know these boundaries well enough to answer that question on the spot isn’t the right agent for a Manhasset purchase. This is precisely the kind of hyperlocal knowledge that makes a real difference in a transaction of this size.
Manhasset has a genuinely old housing stock. The median construction year is 1942, and approximately 47% of homes in the community were built before 1940. That means a significant portion of what’s available — colonial estates, Tudor-style residences, and traditional single-family homes — has decades of renovation history behind it, some of it permitted and some of it not.
When you’re buying a pre-war home at $2+ million in Manhasset, the inspection process carries real weight. You’re looking for aging infrastructure, potential buried oil tanks, unpermitted additions, and deferred maintenance that may not be visible at a showing. An agent who has worked through these transactions on Long Island’s North Shore knows what to flag, which inspectors to bring in, and how to use inspection findings as a negotiation tool rather than a deal-killer. My referral network includes inspectors and contractors who are specifically experienced with older Nassau County housing stock — that’s not a generic resource, it’s a practical one that Manhasset buyers regularly rely on.
The honest answer is that timing depends on your specific situation more than it depends on the market. That said, the market context in Manhasset right now is genuinely favorable for sellers. Inventory is thin, buyer demand from Manhattan commuters and North Shore move-up buyers remains consistent, and prices have appreciated significantly — the median is up 16% year-over-year and has more than doubled since 2012. Long-term homeowners who purchased at earlier price points are sitting on substantial equity, and many haven’t had a professional assessment done in years.
The most useful first step is a complimentary comparative market evaluation, which gives you an accurate picture of what your home is worth in today’s Manhasset market without any commitment to list. From there, you can make a decision based on real numbers rather than assumptions. Spring tends to be the most active selling season on Long Island, with families motivated to close before the school year, but well-priced Manhasset homes attract serious buyers year-round. The bigger variable is pricing accuracy — overpricing in a market this sophisticated, where buyers have done their research, leads to extended days on market and eventual price reductions that cost more than a conservative list price would have.
A Certified Buyer Broker (CBB) is an agent who has completed specialized training in buyer representation and is formally committed to advocating for the buyer’s interests — not split between buyer and seller. In a standard transaction, dual agency situations can arise where the same agent represents both sides. A CBB designation signals that the agent’s training and professional commitment is specifically oriented toward protecting the buyer.
In Manhasset, this matters for a few concrete reasons. First, the transactions here are large — at a median of $2.3 million, you want someone whose job is explicitly to represent your side of the negotiation. Second, since August 2024, the NAR settlement changes require buyers to sign written compensation agreements before touring homes, and the structure of how buyer agents are paid has shifted. A Certified Buyer Broker can walk you through exactly what that agreement means, what compensation looks like, and how it affects your transaction — clearly and without confusion. Third, Manhasset’s market complexity — the village structure, the school district boundaries, the pre-war housing stock — means buyers benefit from an agent who has specifically invested in the skills and knowledge that buyer representation at this level requires.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in Manhasset
